` )( 10 2 ¢3 4 56%879$A@CBD$FE 5GIHQPSR`T UWVXY`baFcedIc

` )( 10 2 ¢3 4 56%879$A@CBD$FE 5GIHQPSR`T UWVXY`baFcedIc

!
798
: ; <>=.?A@1?
B C
" #$&%')(+*,.- #/1032546
D
E
F
G
;IH
J
G K
L
MONQPRSUVXT W [
Y Z]\5^`_ acb5dZfe
gih j(lk6mno(qp% m
rOs$0ut vu4u>2w
‹


£
xy *Uz{z+0uvj10p|(} !~(pf€
M W‚bƒd R bW g…„ 0ut v†‡(‰ˆu2Š63w
Œ. ZfŽ  Z] ^ R g s$0ut vu4u>2w
 _]d R Z’‘ g”“ 0u3*•6…p–6myw
— ˜ P \™š^›W R3œ† gižOŸ¡ ¢ w
¤ _ RoR g¥ 4Upo’0ut 'p¦•w
e§©¨ «ª”¬o­¯®±°–²­´³µ¶² ¨ ®i¸·, ¨}¨ ²–¹
º
! "#$ % 'g & w(
) ,* +.+ -*
=
BD
BQ
N
1 4 g +0 w 6 g + -879+0:7<; w
)/*,+0 132 g + - w 5
+ 0*
>?A@CBDFE G
š²IH KJFJML1®|”­¯®|”­
S
@CBDUTVB Q TXW5E G
>OP@CBQRE
G
6 g + -879+0:7<; w ( []Z\_^ -a`cbd )ih jlk/m
-fegbd
no qpsr tou9v wufx yz|{}r
6h g + - 7:+0 w ( ~/ *o€ g + -‚ +0 w„ƒ ) * + …
k
† u9‡ A {ˆ$‰‹ŠŒr ‰Ž‡.yz‰‰Ž‡‘ ’“Œv ”
•Vu:{g—–Œ˜
‰wu —ŠŒr™ulŒ˜šr qpŒr ›PrœuŒr™‰
6h g + -* 79+ 0* w ( ~ g + -*  + 0* w™ƒ ) * + … g +
k
X²IH<JFJMLUY+­¯®|”­¯®|”­
š²IH KJFJML1®|”­¯®|”­
g
6 g + -879+0 w
k
g
6
+ - 97 + k |+ 79+0 w
w
*- 79+ * w 6 k g + * 97 + 0*
w
r ˜šr™—t Œy |{ 
›zŒv |{ r $sr_{
e
g
w +.*
) * + … + -* 79+ * + *
( g * w- g w„ƒ * g * w g w!#"$&%('*)+,".-/'0")1
 2 * g * w g w 573694 8 z{ + -** :<;= )>)'*)#?A@CB =>D $E'*)#?
Œx uU‡ I F Œx qpsr {}‰R
C GIHKJ‰Œr ‘9‘9‘
L MONQPSR
T UVMOWXR
no qpsr {]yz‰ r V—Šwu — J uU—
Y 3 4 [Z g w
ufrz›q{ G \ ] ^ G {I‡X_ _ r qu9‡ `
y„ufrz r_{ aQb9ced ‚{]yC‰R‰. $|{ V r™srœuK˜„‡‘
f u'h
g‰ ir _ ˆ{ $‰‹ŠŒr|x c{qVŒ˜ V|{IArsŒx – r ‘R˜ ‘
e
+*
j g w
+* k V‰‰5zœ r ˜šr™—t Œy |{ x"
sr A lm xšriJœr™ xšr™Œy—r
C psr u8
œVŒ˜ y $n
J‰ CŒ˜ Arœ!u _ ‘
o
d U W
† psrœ psr
ot uK˜šr u8
 œ C ˜ y $
nJ‰ CŒ˜ ‘
y u8ufr|y |{ ‰ $› gœ ˜ ‘9‘9‘
T UVM WXR
@8E 0.35
@@88EE
NLO
SCHEME 1
SCHEME 2
SCHEME 3
SCHEME 4
0.3
0.25
0.2
0.15
ω
0.1
0.05
0
-0.05
-0.1
-0.15
-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
²U²'® iX²"!'X<JFJ$#¯¬oJ¸ ­´ @ ¬i® Y+­&%(' Ji¬ H*)
+-, ² ¨ ¨ Y+­––@ ¬ X²&X<® JJ:µ9<
;=@ 0u ·'¬¬i'® Y ²Y+>­ ­ 0@J ?cY+, 4Y¬/0 . ¬ Y+¨ ²i¬ ­#yY10²°A, 0 ² G ¨ . Y °¦ ²¬#°Y20¬E †¬š²° ¨ ¬E +436¬58# 7 Y ® Y D 3 ;A°¯ y² ˆHE#|"
5 #i¬«¹G0 ²#JFJH0†JI
Y
i
®
F
u
0
,
·
,
²

:
J
+CB
B
K
ν
E
d RSU k pz uU3ulŒ˜šr ulnJœ x #‡ y u8ufr™‰|{ ‚t Ju'"x"
Œy—r|x
@JuU y„‰ r_{
@ E E
Y5 +i¬²°3 EH # qY ®¯
Š·,², J:#¯¬«¹ 0 B ²JFJH03 I
@šT E
@ E @ E @ T E
S % / % S %
@ E
$# @šT E
S % "! S %
$#
@ E
@ E @ T E
S% % % S %
#'&)(+* "!
@ E *
% "!
pœ { Šsr I ufrcx"
Œyr { qpsr • r ˜šrœ—Š‰R
sr
b M M R
0.6
η = 00.5
1
1.5
2
0.5
ω
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
ν
0.4
0.5
0.6
,
• q psr r|
{ _ ufr yh_ J‰ yzArcx
h ( j e k 4 g w„ƒ g w™ƒ *4 g w
g
5 psr y—ŠŒr™uK˜šr™ yr _ Jwu'œŠsr { ‘9‘9‘
0.3
NLO b=0
b=1
b=2
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
ω
0.05
0
-0.05
-0.1
-0.15
-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
ν
0.6
0.8
1
u pz‚{ r VArœu'r {IAr|x C P b RhN b R M U W qpsr lu nJœxH
#‡ Šsr I { r™u9Šsr { |{  _r {I _ r ‚ t œp ˜psr™u uKxšrœu
y uufrcyq|{ ‘9‘9‘
@
@ EE
, #¯¬ HE#i¬"Y HJ 0 5 µ| ¨ Y+­ J:9 ;:03JI ”
_ J ‰ q
Œxr t,u x J™‰ r œt { —r
œt { r ]
v p ŠŒr A
G
r
G ‰ [ [
k q
ul ‰ V sr & ‰R [& [
qp v qp I{ }wu9‡ r XJ™srœ
^ G & !
G œ
pœ ˜"p rœsr™uK˜ r_{ |{ r {Œxx"‰ r J™ C—
G ™
^
& !
G
( k ‰
— _ J‰ y rc"
. tou G
G G ^ ]
& G r XJ ]
G Œx psr { ul ‰ Vsr ufrzŒx™{ ssv
G r XJ ] ^ G G
&
& G
G x J™‰ r
]
XJ
!
"
#
$&%
G
(
'
(
(
$
(
(
*) +
,
,
,
*) ,
,
G G *) ,
^
G
,
" & ™
-
!
& G  h
^
^ G
/
.
0.71
0.7
0.69
0.68
γ
0.67
0.66
0.65
0.64
0.63
0.62
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
1.5
2
2.5
3
η
1
0.9
λ
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0
0.5
1
η
‰R‰š psr_{ r ufr_{ ‰‹ { v qpz$
u8
œVŒ˜ y $
nJ‰ CŒ˜ ‘
’“Œv A }{ ‰ŽŠsr qpsr “ r|"
. $ db R v p s nJXJu' ‚ _ |{.”
@
@ E E
¯
­
®
J
"
­
0
I
o 0
§
MON
T UVM WXR
!#" %$'&(")*& ,
+ & -.&("'&(/
0 _ &(21 !3 "4&25!#" 61.!3 7' & 2& 859!3 "4& 0 1
:,;=<>@?.ACB@?.DFE G
HJILKNMKPORQS>?.A,T ?.DFEVU
WJKNM'KPOR?SX2Y Z[?.ACB@?SX6\;=<]Z/?SX^B_?.D`\
a b7
Y >@?.ACB@?cEdG ef: IgORQ%Z/?hAK \iHJILKNMKPORQS>@?.AT ?cE(U Ykj>?.AB@?cE
l mm&(7'& n(36&c1 o
a & c1 n & / p&q
")V$'&"]")21p$'&"@1r& n9 21r& 1sn#m& t+ u"wv { y> xzE |q1 /
@ @
n 921r& 1cn9m%& 1c }m ~ 9n 9") &€p&("
l '& nn#"‚ š~ . ƒ
$
-
„ : …C†‡ ˆ †5‰†*ŠŒ‹  „ : …C†*‡‰†*ŠŽ‹ N+ "  † %‘
6 1 ,’ 0 '& +t" }9 "z*&  † ‡ u“ 1c R 
-
-
”
& m &( a " p&
:; < >? A B@?.D E G H IgKNMKPORQ.>? A T ?.DFE
U ef: IgORQ Z/? AK \,U
W KNM'KPO ?kY j ILO Q >?.AB@?.AVU ?cEiZ K T ? K \w;N<>@?.ACB@?.DFE
WJKNM'KPOR? Y j IgORQ > ? A B@? A U ? E iZ~?hKuT KC\,U Y j > ? A B@? A U ? E
; < > ? A U ?2B@?.D E
U
56&c1 / o m|m%&(u“
0 &(n&( 0 &(m%& 6 1
:Z.K B \ ef: IgORQ%Z.KC\U
WJKNM'KPOR?’Y j IgO Q > %B U ? E Z KuT h? KC\ G
O .
K
.
.
.
!
T U ! "$# ) K ) *,+ U - T / K U 0 # ) K T 354 > 7E 6 K
&e %(' K K K
%(2' 1
K
8w1 ~ & !3
U
9 >: E
.K
. K ! .
:
6
sU ! " T / U 0 # T # ) % ' % ' * K
a & 9 %$&
ZR: T : dZ~?hAK ;B .\t\;=<5>?.AB@?.D E G H gI KNQ.>@?.AT .? D E
W K ? - < 9 Z ? KC\ Z ? K T K \ U Y j > ? A B@? A U c? E ; < >? A U ?2B@? D E
?
1
/ K
=?>
(& ")/ 0 0 "~ '& mV- p &(' &"z c1 n9m& '&
& ~ ")21p+N"
1 3R.ƒ3 "4& 0 1
<>=
; $
3
46587
Z Z
\
4
2
9
Z
@
9 5:7
.?&
$
9
9
\
%$ '&
!#"
%$
9
$
A
\ Z \
$
)(+* $-,'%/.01
JLKNMO ;QP 9
RSDTU
#"
TU
9FE
BDC
2
2
G
%
G
2
"
9FE
V&XWY
G 587
.
#"
TU
G
$
7
2
G
G 587
4
I
(]* $^,
G
8._
2
`
G 5:7
a '&("4& a & 21r&
acb
d
e
H
G 5:7
$
2
"
9
7
G 5
9
I

= =
'&ZWY
P
9[\
'3
"4&%&g1 + m!3 l ' & a b7 7 61  &77 0
0
0
-2
f (ka,30,3)[GeV ]
0.025
NLL
0.02
LL, iterative
LL, analytic
0.015
0.01
0.005
0
20
30
35
40
45
50
ka[GeV]
0.025
f (ka,30,5)[GeV ]
-2
25
NLL
0.02
LL, iterative
LL, analytic
0.015
0.01
0.005
0
20
25
30
35
@ @ 7'&s1r& n 1 1s' a a
&€$ $&s1 a &('&"4 
40
45
50
ka[GeV]
7'& /gwm3 0 !3
=
-2
f (25,30,3, λ)[GeV ]
l '& 1 3R!3 61 / 0 &n&( 0 & ,+ +tu" 1c R 0.01
0.009
0.008
0.007
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
λ[GeV]
=
-2
'&
 p&(") ƒ3|1 #"4& '&%& 0 & 0 "4&%&( g1 + m!3
df /d(#iterations) [TeV ]
’ a
3000
/ 0
Y=1
Y=3
Y=5
Y=7
2500
2000
1500
λ=1 GeV
1000
500
0
0
5
10
15
20
iterations
=
n
9 61 '& "‚ a 7 a b7 &'&("z
"‚&2&(g1 + m7!3
-2
f (25,30,Y)[GeV ]
+ '& '3
0.08
0.06
NLL
LL
0.04
0.02
0
0
2
4
6
8
10
Y
=
R*7'& }9" /%+tu" ƒ3 61 '&"‚& @@
-2
f(k a,kb,θ)[GeV ]
0.008
Y=3
Y=5
0.006
0.004
0.002
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
θ [rad]
&(n& 0 &( m& 7 '& 56& &7 a &2&( † ‡
3
& ‹ 0 † Š … Š & ‹ +tu" 7'&
… ‡ mV m& +
0
 l '& "4(& 'u" 61.sq
!3 n( ~% 61 mV,1r& Š 
e
0
e
=
'&('3 &('3f
WK? A
e / ? AK
>EG
W K .? D
e / ? DK
R3 1s 
#
>@?.D E ; >? A B@?.D@BE
$
>@? A E
" a 9" 0 & 1
'& &(" q
%$&( &! "& 1
%$'&s)q ( 0 +* ,-m!+.0/ .1/2m2435, n6,3 0 m!7398
:86<;9=1 >4/c1 …@? A CB 7D FE GB IHKJML N @O A P NRQ<ES!QTQUH5FNB PS V J ‹ 
=XW
l
}m
&0/ 35, /!
m <, 7398 <;
!"#
M3
,<8 8 8 $ m39n<; :81$%$'& 398)( 35,
<; ;5/ %$ / 8( <8 m27398 Z
+Z , * , * .- \
, ,
, * , * . 2
4
3
; $
,*
Z ,*
< =
9
J K MVO ;P 9
I
$
,*
@
9 5:7
4 5:7
9
QP
.
&
9
"
Z
1
+Z , *
"
\ KML
$
$
A
N#N#N
.
"
UT n
2m
,3 / 2
3 8
m
+Z , * , * .- \
6
ON#N#N
C
N#N#N SR
"
<8
B
2
)( 
,*
(+* $-,'
,*
.
1
H
,*
4
(+* $-,
G
,*
2
8.
,*
Vcn:8 <;
3
4 5
9
X
4
G 5:7
3 8 X3 ,
P
.
\ - \ $ '&
9 4
O
$
E
$
@
3
;
@
E
R39; 3 2&
,- * 5 6
87:9;
1
=<
0/01324 0/ , * 1
7398?$M>/ A@CBED FHG BJI 4 5
m
0
;
3
@
l >/ V
=
<; :8 . 6, <8 /
E
4
ZWX, * W WS, * W .- \ 1 87 9;
9 4
3
=ZY
4
ZWS, * W WX, * W .- \
.
G
@
)
I
,
,
+Z * * \ Y
W- S, * W 5 6 5 @ WX, * W WS, * W 0/ WX, * W 1 31 2 4
$
=
;
=
.
.
@
"
@
;
$
@
@
E
$
O
,
*
.
$
fn (|ka| = 20 GeV, |kb| = 30 GeV, Y) [GeV-2]
0.001
0.0001
1e-05
Iterative n = 0
Analytic n = 0
Iterative n = 1
Analytic n = 1
Iterative n = 2
Analytic n = 2
1e-06
1
2
3
4
5
6
Y
9/
( /|m2
,
D FEGE
;^
_
(
1$', / /
H
!#"$
IJKL9MFONPIQ+SR
EG_`"`9a=3?K
"%
%
/ ,
"%
&('*)
/ 8
V!,3
+-,.+/
81$
> 
/ V
/10324156"78:9<;>=3?A@CB
TU=3EC4VW=XFYF)ZY\[\Y\Y]
b(3dcfeg=@C9CcihJc
=t”
7
f (|ka| = 20 GeV, |kb| = 30 GeV, Y, θ) [GeV-2]
0.0007
Full result (Y = 3)
Conformal expansion (Y = 3, n = 4)
(Y = 3, n = 8)
(Y = 3, n = 10)
Full result (Y = 5)
Conformal expansion (Y = 5, n = 4)
(Y = 5, n = 8)
(Y = 5, n = 10)
0.0006
0.0005
0.0004
0.0003
0.0002
0.0001
0
0.5
1
1.5
θ
2
2.5
3
>
&0/ 35, /!
7398 <,
'
<;
6
#"
$
'&
V&
A
)(
T T * 7398
X8 K,-6, /
(/
,
!
- =
-#" B
!
.
2
3 *
&
$
&
$
.
$
2
.
2
%
2
.
3&%
$
1
$
$
.
$ $ $
/ 8!'%
$
1
!,-<8
*
=
)(
-2
f(ka,kb,q,∆y)[GeV ]
1.2
q=0 GeV
q=1 GeV
q=2 GeV
1
0.8
ka=5 GeV,∆y=3
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
kb [GeV]
&0/ 35, /!
$ &0/
:8
%
<;
35,,
6,3
>
7398 <,
'
;+/
* *
UT / ( 398
3&%
%
!#"
$&%
V3
'
(K,3
/
2&1/
%
'
*
UT T
8
*
"
/ , . +.0/
"
*
3
8
/ ,%
*
;8 "
(
"
0
) / ,80/ ;+*
f0 (|ka|, |kb| = 30 GeV, Y = 10) [GeV-2]
10000
LL
NLL
(-1) NLL2
2
NLL no d χ0 (γ) / dγ
100
1
0.01
0.0001
1e-06
1e-08
1e-10
1e-12
1e-06
0.0001
0.01
1
100
10000
1e+06
%
'
1e+08
1e+10
|ka| [GeV]
, /
(
!V3
!&0/
,
, /
3 , / ; /.6<8
R
>/T
)( / ,
(K<; ;
%
2
0.9
-2
f0 (|ka|, |kb| = 30 GeV, Y = 10) [GeV ]
LL
NLL
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
|ka| [GeV]
3
(
,/
,<8<8
2&0/
81$
R3 %
39<;
8
35, R<8 $
4/ ,%
)( 4/ , , /> / , (X3 , /T
'%
%
7398
%
50
&0/ 35, /!
<;
2, 2
!<, /
3
7398 <,
( / ' 7398
&0/ /
WS, * W , * ,* 2
# $ ,&* % ', W , * W+ -, W , * W ( W * W *)
W , * W 4 KML #
)
5 ='
:8 2& &
& '
, / $ <;7 ,
7398 %
!
#
KML (
'?>
A W B * W C F ,*
/1. 0
,"* , * , * # , * 2 , * # , * , * 3
2
%5 796 8;: B WS, * W 2
<
# @ 8;6 :
'?>
"
W B * W B W B * W # F
)ED
KML = =
>HG D
"
IKJ LNM O LQPUTSR T RUPWVSRTP1J XTR AY[ZM\R^]
' a` AcbeB d b > _
_
"
)
>f@
R Y1J-LP J UZM( Y[P
YZM V L RUPM LP
&%
%
! #"%$ & ')(+*, -" # 5
.0/214365
D
beB d b 4 ' 79: 8 7 ; $ b bd > d b b .0/214365@?BA FCED b > d b BG # H ` I J ` > <=; > "
"
d
c
b
b
6
A FEC D > K A FCED < A FCED < 97 8 :EL `
b >d b <
beB d b M A FCED # A FCED ? 5 6 ` b B d b GON ` b B d b 7 8 :EL < L P M R JRQ;R STVUWU R@S J PWR XZY [*( `\O] (-^_`'acb ]
` Id ` F A CED = =0e
F >HG D
R M Z f f Y1J gL P hY SQTL jR i;RV ZM LQhP k]
A Fl cb > d b mon ' 7 s 8 7 ;
pIqr L ` t ;uJvxwzy
b B d b f 798; : ` A Fl cbeB d b # 798; : 5 { A Fl b B d b A Fl
6 L A Fl D e 6
' ` cbeB d b C } L ~€
‚H„ƒ L†… > _`\OL _ ‡ ˆ!‰IŠ‹ LŒ… ` ƒ ) e dW "‘"‘"
— 'D Ž
’ Q Y1J L M “J Q;R R ” •R S J LQP – I ˜
# ` IJ ` | # F
>c™